Voicemail, a person, or an AI?
Four ways to deal with the calls you can't take, compared fairly. We sell one of them, so weigh our view accordingly, but each option suits some businesses better than others.
| Voicemail | Human answering service | Hired receptionist | AI receptionist (The Everything Phone) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Who answers | A recording | A trained person, usually handling several businesses | Your own staff member | An AI, briefed by you |
| Hours | Always | Depends on the plan; many offer extended or 24/7 cover | Their working hours | 24/7 |
| Can answer questions | No | From a script you provide | Yes, with full knowledge | From your brief |
| Books into your calendar | No | Varies; often takes a message | Yes | Yes, checks your real availability |
| What you get afterwards | An audio message | A message by email or text | Whatever they write down | Summary, transcript and recording in Teams |
| How it's charged | Usually included with your phone plan | Typically per call, per minute or a monthly plan | Wages, super, leave | $60/user/month plus The Everything; pooled minutes |
| Caller experience | Many hang up | A human voice | A human who knows you | A natural conversation with an AI |
General descriptions; individual services and plans differ. We have not listed other providers' prices.
When each option makes sense
Stick with voicemail if…
you get very few calls, most of them from people who already know you, and callers are happy to wait for a call back. There's no point paying for something you don't need.
Choose a human answering service if…
your callers expect a person, the calls involve sensitive or emotional situations, or you need someone to follow a strict script for compliance reasons. A good service is a real person doing a real job, and for some callers nothing else will do.
Hire a receptionist if…
you have enough phone and front-desk work to fill the hours, you want someone in the office who can also handle walk-ins, paperwork and the coffee order, and the budget is there.
Choose an AI receptionist if…
you are missing calls because you are working, most calls are enquiries and bookings, you want those bookings to land straight in your calendar, and you want a written record of every call. It's also the only option here that costs about the same at 3am on a Sunday as at 10am on a Tuesday.
Things to be honest with yourself about
Some callers prefer people. An AI receptionist is good, but it isn't a person, and some callers will say so. Say it's an AI in the greeting and offer a call back from a human. Most people just want their problem sorted.
It is only as good as the brief. A receptionist told nothing about your business can only take messages. Ten minutes writing down how you want calls handled makes all the difference.
You still have to call back. The receptionist catches the call and books what it can. The business still runs on you returning calls promptly. The difference is that you know who called, what they wanted, and whether it's already booked.
It works with Microsoft 365. The Everything runs inside Microsoft 365 and Teams. If your business uses something else for email and calendars, this isn't the right fit yet.
See it next to what you use now
Book a free 15-minute demo call. We will show you the app, the transcript in Teams and how a booking lands in your calendar, and answer whatever you want to ask about your own calls.
Prefer to just try it? The 14-day free trial of The Everything needs no credit card.
Demo calls run during Sydney business hours. The times below are shown in your own time zone.
Pick a day and time
Your time zone: Australia/Sydney